Greatest Marketing Campaigns Analysis: Outdoor Ads

This week on Gray Matter: top 5 outdoor ads explored.

Welcome back to Gray Matter, where this week we tackle rating our top five outdoor advertisements! Admittedly, this is no easy task as tracking down creative billboards or other outdoor collateral can be challenging. That said, we’ve narrowed down the list to our favorite 5 outdoor messages to share with you, the reader. So, happy reading and please leave your comments and/or feedback below!

1. “Lightbulb”, The Economist Lightbulb

We start this week with a new find for Gray Matter, which is the Lightbulb billboard created by Abbot Mead Vickers for the Economist. This brilliant piece has a large light bulb surrounded by read empty space. Amazingly, it uses motion detection to ascertain when a person walks by/underneath and in turn, it lights up! In small print we see The Economist listed, thus signifying who the ad is for. This piece uses audience interaction and curiosity to drive their messaging. Countless people walked back and forth engaging with this ad, which is precisely what you want. The objective of the ad was to draw attention to brand and create curiosity/intrigue that drove consumers to their product offerings. Measuring this ad is unique and could easily be overlooked. Rather than measuring sales, the sign actually kept track of the number of engagements (or times it lit up) with patrons.

The target market for this piece is largely the profession crowd, as its location was on a busy city street surrounded by professional workers and offices. Thus, the idea was to attract the audience that is most likely to interact with The Economist. The call to action is simple, to investigate the brand further, to be curious, and to think! The consumer benefits from learning and using their mind, which is the ultimate value proposition as well, where The Economist will aid consumers in becoming smarter and learning!

2. “Submerged”, The Day After Tomorrow Movie Submerged

Another new find for Gray Matter, this billboard was personally interesting as I can recall watching this movie, which centers on a global weather disaster that resembles doomsday. Fittingly, this billboard is located in shallow water of the ocean, half submerged with enough space left to show the movie title and release date. The use of ingenuity and fear come to mind as primary marketing tactics here, where we are all a bit wary of disasters of this level. It is easy to appreciate the design of this ad, while also fearing that something of this nature could happen in real life. These feels merged create a desire to see this movie, which is the ultimate motivation of this billboard ad. The ad can also be easily measured based on its local presence through box office records.

The target audience is clearly movie goers, who most likely fall in the 18–40-year demographic. The ad is conveniently located in an area that is frequented by younger beachgoers. The call to action is very simple, go see the movie and should you do so, you will be entertained! The value proposition is on this same line, whereby movie goers can enjoy maximum entertainment.

3. “Giant Egg”, MacDonald’s Cracked Egg

This remarkable advertisement was placed in Chicago, and I recall hearing about this years ago. It is basically a giant egg placed on a billboard like post many feet in the air. Looking closely, you can ascertain there is a slight crack running through the egg. Below, rests a popular MacDonald’s location and using animatronics, at specific times of the day (such as breakfast) the egg will open and crack itself, showing a lovely image of a delicious fried eggs inside. This ad uses humor and wonder to impact audiences, as you can only imagine folks flocked to see this take place. Once there, why not order some MacDonalds? The objectives are clear, driving traffic and revenue through the local location, while also reminding customers there is always time for breakfast! Measurement was achieved by simply monitoring store sales post installation of this advertisement.

The target audience here is wide, ranging from very young to very old. It largely encompasses those who live locally, as well as some nearby highway traffic. Transparently, anyone who is hungry falls into the target pool. The call to action is to remember that breakfast is served at all hours at this MacDonald’s, thus pushing traffic through the store. The value proposition and benefit come from getting a tasty breakfast meal at any time of the day!

4. “Disneyland”, Alaska Airlines The Plane

This choice is one I have long admired, and Alaska Airlines isn’t the only one to do this through the years. However, they were the first to my recollection and as such, earn the right to be mentioned here. The airline wrapped several plans within their fleet in a Disney themed skin, which depicts all of Disney’s most prominent characters (Mickey Mouse, Donald Duck, etc.). With pictures running down the plane, surrounded in bright blue colors, the planes become a flying billboard advertisement! This piece is creative and uses emotion and memory as a powerful motivator (and reminder). The objective is to call attention to and remind customers of the magic and fun that Disney provides both kids and adults. Now, measuring this campaign isn’t easy, though Alaska Airlines did run some specials during flights attempting to have folks sign up for vacations, which offers one route of tracking.

The target audience is likely the 25–40-year-old segment, though it can easily range outside of that demographic. The ad resonates more with young parents of those with toddler aged children. Once again, the call to action is simple remembering all the magic and wonder that Disney offered them when they were little. The underlying motivator is to drive attendance and sales of Disney parks. The value proposition and benefits are similar, where parents can offer their children magical memories that they can one day look back on fondly as well!

5. “Story of the Open”, The US Open Tennis Tournament (New York) The Open

Closing out the list this week is the US Open Tennis Tournament’s use of “The Story of the Open” billboard located squarely in New York City. With bright colors and interactive images, the billboard displays a large hashtag “story of the open”. The ad is calling for viewers to interact and utilize the hashtag to help tell the true story of this open. Thus, the piece uses interaction and social culture as a driver to meet the objective of hyping up the US Open. While attendance to the event is certainly a welcome consequence, it is largely focused on creating social media buzz and interaction across the world. This advertisement is incredibly easy to measure, as it created millions of interactions and storytelling instances on social media, making it one of the highest tough sporting ads of all time.

Simple yet effective, this piece speaks to the 18–40-year-old demographic who are eager to share their experiences and thoughts online. The ad capitalizes on the trend of the younger generation needed to have their voices heard. The action step is for viewers to engage with the hashtag and interact through sharing their own “open story” via social media. In so doing, the viewer can benefit by having their voice heard and sharing their own unique thoughts with the world. The value proposition mirrors this take, making this unique billboard a wonderful example of how effective marketing can drive trends.

References:

Marwan. (2020a, August 6). 55 Best Billboard and outdoor ads of all Time – Empire Group. Empire Group. https://theempire.com/best-billboard-ads/

Staff, S. O. T. T. (2022, October 3). 35 of the Best Outdoor Advertisements You’ll Ever Find. Signs of the Times. https://signsofthetimes.com/best-outdoor-advertisements/

Tags:

Responses to “Greatest Marketing Campaigns Analysis: Outdoor Ads”

  1. Tonya T Thomas

    Hi Zane,

    The “lightbulb” billboard was clever. If I came across it, I would go back and forth under it in wonder as well. They use the wonder of what and why to get the consumer to take notice. It’s very interactive and a lot of marketers are seeing the power of interactive messages to their audiences. I also thought the”submerged” sign was very interesting. The submerged sign creates suspense, wonder, and a bit of eerieness to lure the audience to opening night. The local McDonald’s sign seemed to be the most results-driven as it was strategically placed to target any hungry customer to come on inside for breakfast. As you stated, the result would have probably been more immediate by watching breakfast sales rise. Also, I remember pointing out a Disney plane to one of my children to increase the suspense and excitement they were feeling during our travel to Disneyworld.

    Like

    1. zanebreeding7

      Tonya,
      Thanks for reading! The lightbulb billboard was truly one of the most interesting pieces I have seen in this course. Undoubtedly expensive, its unique nature forces consumers to think, whether about the bulb or the brand, which is precisely what the parent company wants. There is no immediate “call to action” to purchase, but rather to think! In my mind that can be a really powerful motivator itself!

      Cheers,
      Zane Breeding

      Like

  2. The Professional Student

    Zane,

    I think looking at outdoor advertisements was one of the most interesting aspects of the greatest marketing campaigns assignment. I have found that billboards and outdoor advertisements seem much more attention-grabbing than print advertisements in magazines or newspapers. By attention-grabbing, I am referring to both content and the colors used to communicate what is being advertised. Maybe it is the sheer size of billboards I am fascinated with. I also like bus stop advertisements as I feel like they have a far greater reach than a newspaper and a magazine because people do not have to make a purchase to see them. They are just there in plain sight. What are your thoughts on outdoor advertisements? What is your favorite advertising medium? Great job on the assignment, and I am excited to keep reading Gray Matter Musings.

    Kindly,

    Shawn

    Like

    1. zanebreeding7

      Shawn,
      Thanks for posting! Outdoor ads was a really neat vertical to dive into and one I had honestly, overlooked. I have multiple friends who are small business owners who regularly advertise via billboard and several also use car wrapping. Per their feedback, billboard advertising seems to be most effective for smaller regional businesses where you are appealing to a “home base” or local crowd. Thus, you are basically reminding your target audience of your services each time they drive by, which is a great way to offer subliminal messaging. The largest challenge I see with billboard/outdoor advertising is simply location. Typically, there are only a few elite locations from which to advertise if you are looking at fixed signage, so ensuring you locate properly is likely half the battle. Mobile ads like car wrapping offer the ability to travel and can boost brand recognition, though I wasn’t able to find much data on just how successful they are from a measurement capacity. Ultimately, I am a man of written word. For whatever reason, I still find magazine and print articles to be the most persuasive from a marketing aspect. I appreciate the diligence and brilliance it takes to craft a successful ad in this format, whether through pictures, color schemes, or words. Perhaps its more of an appreciation for the art behind print marketing that sways me!

      Cheers,
      Zane Breeding

      Like

  3. Taelor Eyre

    Zane,

    Great ads; they were all very intriguing! I love a great outdoor Ad. There tend to be some creative billboards on the drive out to Palm Springs this year, for companies are trying to target the Coachella and Stagecoach attendees. I always appreciate a good billboard when I’m caught in Los Angeles traffic. The Submerged ad caught my eye, I’ve never seen an ad like it. I would be very curious if I saw a billboard half submerged in the Santa Monica ocean, or any ocean for that matter. The Economist light bulb ad is a fantastic idea, and I’d be willing to bet a great selfie opportunity too which would extend the ads reach onto social media. I see a lot of outdoor ads like this in Los Angeles that serve as an ad but also a photo op that will then go on to circulate on the social media platforms; it’s brilliant in my opinion. 

    Great work!

    Taelor 

    Like

    1. zanebreeding7

      Taelor,

      Thanks for chiming in! Great call out with Coachella, which is an interesting opportunity for advertisers to target a specific demographic that will be uniquely geographically located for a period of time. As you reference LA, it might be interesting to dig into the data to understand what some common billboard real estate might run you in downtown LA versus somewhere here in North Carolina. I imagine the variance is very drastic, but it speaks to how important proper marketing strategy is, even when dealing with outdoor advertising. Great feedback and thanks again for checking in!

      Cheers,
      Zane Breeding

      Like

  4. ivanhuffman

    Zane,

    Your ad selection is amazing! These ads do something that your others analysis’s have not. These ads have placed brands in a way that I don’t think anyone would expect. The Disneyland Livery on Alaska Airlines, a giant Egg on a McDonalds and a lightbulb on a city street. These larger than life ads allow us to think and connect companies that I don’t think normally go together. These partnerships and designs are why I love marketing!

    Like

Leave a reply to The Professional Student Cancel reply